Jolee

Jolee was so desperate to get pregnant and have a baby that she slept with her mother's fiance named Steve. Around the same time, she also slept with her ex-boyfriend named Mike. She soon got pregnant with her daughter Breanna. Jolee said she had sex with Steve once and told her mother Judy right away who was "shocked and she was really hurt". Judy then kicked Jolee out of her house. When pictures of Breanna, Steve and Mike were displayed on the screen, Maury asked Jolee who she thinks Breanna looks like, she replied Mike but the audience yelled “Neither!”

Steve admitted he was under the influence at the time he and Jolee had sex. He promised to be there for Breanna either as a father or grandfather. Mike could not appear on the show but in a video message, he promised to be in Breanna’s life if proven to be the father.

Upon finding out that Mike was not the father, Jolee ran backstage crying. Steve and Maury escorted her back on the set and Maury revealed that Steve also was not the father. Judy, who was sitting in the audience, said “Thank god.” Jolee admitted she had no idea who the father was.

On an update episode, it was revealed that there were three more men who could be Breanna's father, but Jolee did not return to the show.