Brent and Katie

17 year old Brent appeared on the show with his mother Joanna to find out if he was the father of 26 year old Katie's daughter Ciara. Brent admitted he had sex with Katie "a number of times" when he was 14 and Joanna found out Katie was nearly 10 years older when learning she was pregnant. Joanna also learned Katie was divorced with 2 other children.

Katie slept with several other of Joanna's family members, including her brother Bill, though he was not tested for paternity. After living with Brent and Joanna for seven months, she left unannounced and Joanna later found pictures on Facebook of Katie with her daughter and another man, who Katie said was Cierra's father. After they broke up a year later, Katie contacted Joanna on Facebook saying that Brent was Ciara's father. While he and his mother believed he was the father, they wanted DNA proof.

Maury asked Brent what he was doing with a 24 year old woman, and he said he slept with Katie "for bragging rights". He said he heard rumors Katie slept with other men, including his uncle, after they got into an argument and she said he wasn't the father. Maury asked "You grew up watching my show, didn't you learn anything?"

After coming out backstage, she said she had sex with Brent and her ex at the time she got pregnant. She said she "had a wild streak" after her mother died and did "whatever I could to make myself feel better". She denied sleeping with other men.

Bill said that Katie is a known liar and he believes Brent is not Ciara's father. He regretted having sex with Katie.

The DNA test proved that Brent was the father of Ciara but why the hell is she not in prison ?