Jessica

Jessica, then 19 years old, was hired by Don and Amy to babysit their children, but she had a sexual relationship with their son Steven, then 14, got pregnant and claimed he fathered her daughter Cheyenne. Don and Amy said they had no idea Jessica and Steven were having sex and they both admitted that they had sex behind his parent's backs but said he was the father of Cheyenne. Jessica called Don a "deadbeat grandpa" while he called her a "child molesting whore". When Jessica came out from backstage, security had to restrain her, Amy and Don. Jessica downplayed Don's allegations that she is a child molester. Steven vowed to stay with her even if he was not Cheyenne's father. The DNA test proved he was not the father.

They returned a few weeks later and Jessica claimed Don was the father of Cheyenne. He called her a “nasty, dirty, home wrecking tramp” but a lie detector proved that Don had sex with Jessica and believed he fathered Cheyenne. However, he also was proven not to be the father. Jessica said she met a man at a bar, whose name she didn’t remember, and they went back to his hotel room to have sex. She admitted she slept with two other men around the time she got pregnant.

Jessica and Steven got married and they returned a third time when Don accused Jessica on cheating with a family friend. Jessica admitted to the lie detector administrator she cheated with another man but the lie detector test proved she did not cheat with the family friend.

In an "After the Results" episode, Steven said he and Jessica are now divorced.