Vena gave birth to fraternal twins named Tagan and Peyton but around the time she got pregnant, she slept with an ex-boyfriend. Chad said he found out he may not be the father of the twins after they were born. Maury asked Chad if he knew that with fraternal twins, there was a chance he could be the father of only one of them and Chad said "Yes, I've done a lot of reading and a lot of looking."

Vena admitted she didn't tell Chad she cheated until after the twins were born.

The DNA test revealed that Chad fathered Tagan but not Peyton. Maury appeared shocked after he read the results. Audience members were also seen with stunned looks on their faces.