14 year old Decardo and his mother Oleta were on the show to prove to 20 year old Quintara that he was not the father of her baby. Decardo said he lost his virginity to Quintara when he was 13 and she was 19, but never thought he could get her pregnant. He said that he was not ready to be a dad. Maury said it was "completely unacceptable for an older woman to have sex with a 13 year old." He said that Quintara told his producers that she was not sorry for having sex, rather, for getting pregnant.

Quintara admitted to sleeping with Decardo four or five times and that she knew it was wrong. But she said she needed help from Decardo and his mother to help raise her baby. When she came out on the set, Maury told her "There are a lot of people watching this show today both in our live audience and back home are saying you committed a crime." She said she didn't know it at the time, but "it is what it is.".She said she didn't want Decardo to be the father and the DNA test revealed he wasn't.